Universal rapid method of assessment and management decision-making of situational problems in the enterprise
https://doi.org/10.20914/2310-1202-2019-2-359-376
Abstract
Situational approach in management does not lose its relevance for a hundred years. During this time he constantly developed, being a part of various concepts, methodologies, methods, techniques and other forms of theoretical and practical implementation of scientific thought in different areas of human activity. The results of the analysis of scientific sources in the article over the past eight years confirmed the presence of the situational approach unlimited development potential. As one of the ways to develop the situational approach, the authors propose a new method of evaluation and management decision-making problems of a situational nature in the enterprise. In contrast to the existing methods, the proposed method is characterized by a high level of efficiency and versatility. The methodology provides decisions to the problems of situational nature of the three categories of complexity. For each category there are special forms in the form of different hierarchies. To reduce the number of possible errors and improve the efficiency of the methodology implementation, a special algorithm, as well as the necessary instructions for users, have been developed and presented. In addition, various information technologies are provided as tools for the implementation of the methodology. The method of analysis of T. Saati hierarchies was used as the core of the new method. The method of decision-making by Benjamin Franklin was adopted as a complement of the method. The final part of the article presents the results of testing the proposed method. In the majority of users of a technique really noted its universal and express properties. Thus, according to the results of testing at the enterprises, the technique is recognized as effective and viable.
About the Authors
D. A. Shageev
International Institute of Design and Service
Russian Federation
Cand. Sci. (Econ.), associate professor, economics and management department, Voroshilova str., 12, Chelyabinsk, 454014, Russia
Russian Federation
Cand. Sci. (Econ.), associate professor, economics and management department, Voroshilova str., 12, Chelyabinsk, 454014, Russia
T. A. Chuhonceva
International Institute of Design and Service
student, economics and management department, Voroshilova str., 12, Chelyabinsk, 454014, Russia
student, economics and management department, Voroshilova str., 12, Chelyabinsk, 454014, Russia
References
1. Alekhina L.L., Alekhina A.A. Situation management: approaches and solutions. Bulletin OrelGIEHT. 2014. no. 3. pp. 23–27. (in Russian).
2. Barchukov A.V., Kradenyh I.A. Assessment of efficiency and identification of problems of the gold mining industry by methods of situational analysis. In the collection: Topical issues of project and process management. Proceedings of the all-Russian scientific-practical conference with international participation of scientists of transport universities and representatives of academic science; ed. S.N. Tret'yaka. 2014. pp. 12–19. (in Russian).
3. Goncharova E.V., Kurlovich A.I. Features of the situational approach to decision-making in the economy. Scientific and methodical electronic journal «Concept». 2017. vol. 39. pp. 1436–1440. (in Russian).
4. Goncharova E.V., Bozheskova A.A. The role of a systematic approach and situational analysis in the management decision-making process. Scientific and methodical electronic journal «Concept». 2017. vol. 39. pp. 4252–4256. (in Russian).
5. Ermakova E.M., Agafonova M.S. Application of systemic and situational approaches in reforming the organizational structure of management. Scientific review. Economics. 2016. no. 2. pp. 68–73. (in Russian).
6. Zhuravlev V.V., Varkova N.Yu., Pishchulina E.S. Current trends in international and Russian experience in the formation of personnel policy. Economy and entrepreneurship. 2018. no. 3 (92). pp. 552–557. (in Russian).
7. Zacarinnyj A.A., Suchkov A.P. System technical approaches to the creation of decision support system based on situational analysis. Informatics and its applications. 2016. vol. 10. no. 4. pp. 105–113. (in Russian).
8. Kulikova O.I. Instability and uncertainty in the situational approach to the management of organizations. Tiered social reproduction: theoretical and practical issues. 2014. no. 6 (22). pp. 215–222. (in Russian).
9. Kulinich A.A. Situational, cognitive and semiotic approaches to decision-making in organizations. Open education. 2016. vol. 20. no. 6. pp. 9–17. (in Russian).
10. Kuzheleva S.A. The system of information support of decision-making to manage the competitiveness of the University on the basis of situational approach. News of southwest state University: Series Management, computer engineering, computer science. Medical instrumentation. 2012. no. 2–3. pp. 194–198. (in Russian).
11. Saaty T.L. The magic number seven in nature. Cloud of Science. 2017. vol. 4. no. 1. pp. 5–33.
12. Saaty T.L. Relative measurement and its generalization in decision-making. Why pairwise comparisons are Central to mathematics to measure intangible factors. Cloud of Science. 2016. vol. 3. no. 2. pp.171–262.
13. Saaty T.L. On the measurement of the intangible. An approach to relative measurements based on the main eigenvector of the pair comparison matrix. Cloud of Science. 2015. vol. 2. no. 1. pp. 5–39.
14. Saaty T. Decision making with dependence and feedback. Moscow, LKI, 2008. 360 p. (in Russian).
15. Saaty T. Decision making. Hierarchy analysis method. Moscow, Radio i sviaz. 1993. 278 p. (in Russian).
16. Titov A.V. Mathematical support of situational approach to the management of complex objects. book: managing the development of large-scale systems (MLSD'2011). Proceedings of the fifth international conference; ed. S.N. Vasil'ev, A.D. Cvirkun. 2011. pp. 140–143. (in Russian).
17. Titov A.V. Management decision-making system based on fuzzy similarity measures. IDO Science. 2010. no. 2. pp. 87–89. (in Russian).
18. Ulanova T.V. Features of improving the efficiency of personnel of JSC "Russian Railways" on the example of the Franklin method. In the collection: Management – a modern technology for coordinating activities, a collection of articles from an international scientific and practical conference. 2016. pp. 173–177. (in Russian).
19. Franklin B. About freedom and necessity, pleasure and suffering. Moscow, Ehksmo, 2016. 155 p. (in Russian).
20. Franklin B. Way to riches: the autobiography. Moscow, Ehksmo, 2016. 438 p. (in Russian).
21. Shageev D.A., Peregrimova I.M. Methodic of development of coordinated management decisions of distribution of net profit at the enterprise. Proceedings of VSUET. 2018. vol. 80. no. 3. pp. 392–415. (in Russian).
22. Shageev D.A., Peregrimova I.M. Development of the Balanced Managerial Decision on Formation of an Investment Portfolio for an Individual in Historical and Modern Aspects. Bulletin of the South Ural State University. Ser. Economics and Management. 2017. vol. 11. no. 1. pp. 86–98. (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Shageev D.A., Chuhonceva T.A. Universal rapid method of assessment and management decision-making of situational problems in the enterprise. Proceedings of the Voronezh State University of Engineering Technologies. 2019;81(2):359-376. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.20914/2310-1202-2019-2-359-376
Views:
612
Email this article 
Post a Comment 
