Preview

Proceedings of the Voronezh State University of Engineering Technologies

Advanced search

Study of color characteristics of bakery products made from wheat flour at different baking times

https://doi.org/10.20914/2310-1202-2026-1-133-141

Abstract

According to regulatory documents, the color of bakery products is determined by organoleptic analysis, an essential fault of which is the assessment subjectivity. Instrumental analysis is widely used currently in world practice to evaluate the color characteristics of various food products, including bakery products. The most widely used colorimetric system is the CIE Lab. The aim of the study was to determine the effect of baking time in an electrical sole oven on the color characteristics of bakery products made from patent wheat flour. The objects of the study were products prepared according to the recipe for long loaf with different baking times (15-40 min). Samples of bakery products were examined by organoleptic analysis (taste, crust color, crumb color, bread aroma, crumb aroma, crumb condition). The analysis of the color characteristics of the crust and crumb was performed using a colorimeter Chroma meter CR-410 (Konica Minolta, Japan) in the CIE Lab system. The studies have shown that with increasing baking time, the lightness (L*) decreases from 72.60±1.75% to 48.75±1.43%; the parameter b* decreases significantly starting from 35 minutes of baking from 23.43±0.28° to 15.42±1.30°; while the parameter a* initially increases from 6.40±1.12° to a peak value of 10.57±0.43° by 30 minutes of baking, and then decreases. Comparison of the results of the color characteristics of the bakery product with the results of the organoleptic analysis made it possible to establish the ranges of color characteristics L* (55-68%) and a* (9-11°), at which the color of the bread crust and the product as a whole is positively assessed by tasters. The b* parameter did not have an unambiguous correlation with the results of the organoleptic analysis. Using the international CIE Lab system for measuring bakery product color characteristics, it has been proven that the most informative values for assessing the crust color of wheat flour products are the characteristics “L*” and “a*”, which correlate with the organoleptic assessment of these products. These characteristics can be used as visual indicators in the automatic baking time control process.

About the Authors

L. V. Zaytseva
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry
Russian Federation

Dr. Sci. (Engin.), chief researcher, center for food rheology, 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



D. Y. Sotchenko
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry

junior researcher, center for food rheology, 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



A. Y. Ignatov
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry

engineer, center for food rheology, 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



Y. Y. Pechnikova
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry

junior researcher, center for food rheology, 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



K. A. Baluyan
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry

Cand. Sci. (Engin.), senior researcher, center for food rheology, 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



V. V. Martirosyan
Scientific Research Institute for the Baking Industry

Dr. Sci. (Engin.), deputy director for researches, , 26A, B. Cherkizovskaya str., Moscow, 107553, Russia



References

1. Bykovskaya E.I., Kovaleva A.E., Pyanikova E.A., Govyadova A.I. Analysis of Quality Indicators of Whole Grain Bread on Hop Sourdoughs. Bulletin of VSUET. 2023. vol. 85. no. 1. pp. 71–78. doi: 10.20914/2310-1202-2023-1-71-78 (in Russian).

2. Khlopov A.A., Efimenko S.G., Lybenko E.S. Influence of Linseed Flour on the Quality of Rye Bread. Bulletin of VSUET. 2024. vol. 86. no. 2. pp. 74–80. doi: 10.20914/2310-1202-2024-2-74-80 (in Russian).

3. Veber A.L., Leonova S.A. Possibilities of Using Plant Dispersion from Legume Grain to Improve the Properties of Wheat Bread. Bulletin of VSUET. 2024. vol. 86. no. 2. pp. 213–223. doi: 10.20914/2310-1202-2024-2-213-223 (in Russian).

4. Drannikov A.V., Shevtsov A.A., Polyansky K.K., Dombrovskaya Ya.P. et al. Development of Technology for Wheat-Triticale Bread Resistant to Microbiological Spoilage. Bulletin of VSUET. 2024. vol. 86. no. 1. pp. 56–62. doi: 10.20914/2310-1202-2024-1-56-62 (in Russian).

5. Chen W., Wu X., Liu Z. et al. The impact of illuminance level, correlated colour temperature and viewing background on the purchase intention for bread and cakes. Food Quality and Preference. 2022. vol. 98. article 104537. doi: 10.1016/j.foodqual.2022.104537.

6. Baluyan Kh.A., Zaitseva L.V., Pechnikova Yu.Yu. et al. Prospects for the Use of Instrumental Methods in Determining the Color of Bakery Products (A Thematic Review). Food Industry. 2025. no. 6. pp. 71–75. doi: 10.52653/PPI.2025.6.6.015 (in Russian).

7. Horvath A., Kajdi F., Doka O. Classification of flours based on color measurements and evaluation using multivariate mathematical methods. Heliyon. 2025. vol. 11. no. 16. article e44096. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2025.e44096.

8. Fatima S., Altemimi A.B., Ali K. et al. A comprehensive review on effect of chia seed, flaxseed, sesame seed and their derivatives on quality of bakery products. Applied Food Research. 2025. vol. 5. no. 1. article 101534. doi: 10.1016/j.afres.2025.101534.

9. Mussio C., Del Vecchio L., García-Pérez P. et al. Hemp flour enriched bread: effect on metabolomic and technological profile following in vitro digestion. Food Chemistry. 2026. vol. 500. article 147515. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2025.147515.

10. Qin Y., Jiang K., Song J. et al. Effect of roselle and purple rice powder on baking quality and aroma characteristic of bread. LWT. 2024. vol. 199. article 116134. doi: 10.1016/j.lwt.2024.116134.

11. Abdi R., Sharma M., Cao W. et al. Sprouted wheat wholemeal as a techno-functional ingredient in hard pretzels. Food Research International. 2024. vol. 194. article 114878. doi: 10.1016/j.foodres.2024.114878.

12. Seo Y., Moon Y., Kweon M. Effect of purple-colored wheat bran addition on quality and antioxidant property of bread and optimization of bread-making conditions. Applied Sciences. 2021. vol. 11. no. 9. article 4034. doi: 10.3390/app11094034.

13. Tayefe M., Fadayi Eshkiki L., Rahbar Dalir Z., Nasrollahzadeh Masoule A. Optimization of green tea extract, rosemary extract, and rice bran in multifunctional bread: A concept for reduction of acrylamide and phytic acid. Heliyon. 2025. vol. 11. article e41182. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e41182.

14. Sokurova D.A., Zaporozhets G.S., Smetankina V.S. et al. Evaluation of the Color of Bakery Products with the Addition of Ground Safflower Using a Colorimeter. Sursky Bulletin. 2020. vol. 11. no. 3. pp. 65–70. (in Russian).

15. Akbarbaglu Z., Mazloomi N., Sarabandi K. et al. Stabilization of antioxidant thyme-leaves extract (Thymus vulgaris) within biopolymers and its application in functional bread formulation. Future Foods. 2024. vol. 9. article 100356. doi: 10.1016/j.fufo.2024.100356.

16. Pereira T., Costa S., Barroso S. et al. Development and optimization of high-protein and low-saturated fat bread formulations enriched with lupin and microalgae. LWT. 2024. vol. 191. article 115612. doi: 10.1016/j.lwt.2023.115612.

17. Cannas M., Conte P., Urgeghe P.P. et al. Artichoke by-products: Promising ingredients for breadstick fortification. LWT. 2024. vol. 202. article 116307. doi: 10.1016/j.lwt.2024.116307.

18. Mohanakumar A., Dhenge R., Alinovi M. et al. The effect of natural basil extract on oxidative stability and techno-functional properties of breadsticks. LWT. 2025. vol. 227. article 117987. doi: 10.1016/j.lwt.2025.117987.

19. Perfilova O.V., Bryksina K.V., Ivanova E.P., Tolstova N.Yu. Influence of Fruit and Vegetable Pastes on Organoleptic Quality Indicators of Rye-Wheat Bread. Science and Education. 2022. no. 4. pp. 205–207. (in Russian).

20. Maslov A.V., Mingaleeva Z.Sh., Yamashev T.A., Starovoitova O.V. Influence of a Complex Additive on the Color Characteristics of Wheat and Rye-Wheat Bread. News of Universities. Food Technology. 2023. no. 4. pp. 45–51. doi: 10.26297/0579-3009.2023.4.8 (in Russian).

21. Pokuah A.A., Atuna R.A., Akabanda F., Amagloh F.K. Enrichment of bread with soymilk using response surface methodology. Food Chemistry Advances. 2024. vol. 4. article 100570. doi: 10.1016/j.focha.2023.100570.

22. Nilova L.P., Malyutenkova S.M. The Use of Mesquite Powder in the Production of Gluten-Free Cookies. XXI Century: Results of the Past and Problems of the Present Plus. 2023. vol. 12. no. 4. pp. 154–159. (in Russian).

23. Penalver R., Nieto G. Developing a functional gluten-free sourdough bread by incorporating quinoa, amaranth, rice and spirulina. LWT. 2024. vol. 201. article 116162. doi: 10.1016/j.lwt.2024.116162.

24. Tok Ö., Tuncel N.B. The effect of microwave-assisted hydrothermal treatment on physicochemical and functional properties of wheat, barley, and rye flours. Journal of Cereal Science. 2024. vol. 117. article 103925. doi: 10.1016/j.jcs.2024.103925.

25. Khuzin F.K., Yamashev T.A., Kanarsky A.V., Gematdinova V.M. Influence of the Baking Method and Recipe Composition of Bakery Products on the Color Characteristics of Their Surface. Khleboprodukty. 2020. no. 1. pp. 56–59. doi: 10.32462/0235-2508-2020-29-1-56-59 (in Russian).

26. Pechnikova Yu.Yu., Chernykh V.Ya. Assessment of the Uniformity of the Temperature Field of the Baking Chamber of the PPE-800P-1 Oven. In: Polandov Readings: Collection of Materials of the VII International Scientific and Practical Youth Conference. Moscow: FSBSI RIHP, 2025. pp. 147–152. (in Russian).


Review

For citations:


Zaytseva L.V., Sotchenko D.Y., Ignatov A.Y., Pechnikova Y.Y., Baluyan K.A., Martirosyan V.V. Study of color characteristics of bakery products made from wheat flour at different baking times. Proceedings of the Voronezh State University of Engineering Technologies. 2026;88(1):133-141. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.20914/2310-1202-2026-1-133-141

Views: 201

JATS XML


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2226-910X (Print)
ISSN 2310-1202 (Online)